pub10: candidates: 5 rows where adjudicator = "rejected" and app

Every statement both blind runs produced (3,819), with its full trail: script check → verifier verdict and reason → adjudicator ruling and reason → whether it is in the final set. Most rejections are duplicates between the two runs.

Data license: Not yet licensed — internal review only · Data source: Ahmed ElBatanony, Innopolis University

5 rows where adjudicator = "rejected" and app_id = "F1-005"

descending

✎ View and edit SQL

This data as json, CSV (advanced)

candidate_id ▼	app_id	run	statement	excerpt	source_url	source_file	script_check	verifier_verdict	verifier_reason	adjudicator	adjudicator_reason
F1-005-A035	DeskcommCRM F1-005	a	The system lets an administrator reset a user's password	\| `reset-password.sh` \| Resets a user's password \|	https://raw.githubusercontent.com/melgarafael/DeskcommCRM/HEAD/README.en.md	04.txt	passed	rejected	Shell script run on the VPS by the server operator; IT-infrastructure administration, not a business-role feature.	rejected	The excerpt is a server shell script run by the installation operator, which is IT-infrastructure administration rather than an in-app feature.
F1-005-A036	DeskcommCRM F1-005	a	The system lets an administrator remove two-factor authentication for a user who lost their phone	\| `reset-mfa.sh` \| Removes MFA for someone who lost their phone \|	https://raw.githubusercontent.com/melgarafael/DeskcommCRM/HEAD/README.en.md	04.txt	passed	rejected	Shell script run on the VPS by the server operator; IT-infrastructure administration, not a business-role feature.	rejected	MFA removal here is an operator shell script on the server, not a user-facing sign-in feature of the app.
F1-005-A056	DeskcommCRM F1-005	a	The system lets an administrator back up the database and WhatsApp sessions	\| `backup.sh` \| Backs up the database + WhatsApp sessions \|	https://raw.githubusercontent.com/melgarafael/DeskcommCRM/HEAD/README.en.md	04.txt	passed	rejected	Shell script run on the VPS by the server operator; IT-infrastructure administration, not a business-role feature.	rejected	Database backup by shell script is IT-infrastructure administration that no business role uses.
F1-005-A057	DeskcommCRM F1-005	a	The system lets an administrator restore a backup into an empty database	it only restores into an empty database	https://raw.githubusercontent.com/melgarafael/DeskcommCRM/HEAD/README.en.md	04.txt	passed	rejected	Shell script run on the VPS by the server operator; IT-infrastructure administration, not a business-role feature.	rejected	Restoring a backup by shell script is IT-infrastructure administration that no business role uses.
F1-005-B060	DeskcommCRM F1-005	b	The system lets a user manage notifications	Profile, Notifications, Billing	https://raw.githubusercontent.com/melgarafael/DeskcommCRM/HEAD/README.en.md	04.txt	passed	rejected	Bare screen label in a list; the excerpt does not say what a user can do with notifications.	rejected	A bare settings-tab label does not say what a user can do with notifications.

Advanced export

JSON shape: default, array, newline-delimited, object

CREATE TABLE [candidates] ([candidate_id] TEXT PRIMARY KEY, [app_id] TEXT, [run] TEXT, [statement] TEXT, [excerpt] TEXT, [source_url] TEXT, [source_file] TEXT, [script_check] TEXT, [verifier_verdict] TEXT, [verifier_reason] TEXT, [verifier_correction] TEXT, [adjudicator] TEXT, [adjudicator_reason] TEXT, [in_final_set] REAL, FOREIGN KEY ([app_id]) REFERENCES apps(app_id));
CREATE INDEX [idx_candidates_app_id] ON [candidates]([app_id]);
CREATE INDEX [idx_candidates_run] ON [candidates]([run]);
CREATE INDEX [idx_candidates_verifier_verdict] ON [candidates]([verifier_verdict]);
CREATE INDEX [idx_candidates_adjudicator] ON [candidates]([adjudicator]);