pub10: candidates: 30 rows where adjudicator = "rejected", run = "b" and verifier

Every statement both blind runs produced (3,819), with its full trail: script check → verifier verdict and reason → adjudicator ruling and reason → whether it is in the final set. Most rejections are duplicates between the two runs.

Data license: Not yet licensed — internal review only · Data source: Ahmed ElBatanony, Innopolis University

30 rows where adjudicator = "rejected", run = "b" and verifier_verdict = "rejected"

descending

✎ View and edit SQL

This data as json, CSV (advanced)

candidate_id ▼	app_id	run	statement	excerpt	source_url	source_file	script_check	verifier_verdict	verifier_reason	adjudicator	adjudicator_reason
F1-001-B043	Operately F1-001	b	The system automatically requires a project start date when a project template is selected	Project start date — Required when you select a template.	https://operately.com/help/create-project	06.txt	passed	rejected	A validation rule on a form field, not a capability.	rejected	A required-field validation rule is not a capability.
F1-001-B080	Operately F1-001	b	The system automatically prevents a goal from having more than one draft check-in at a time	Each goal can have only one draft check-in at a time.	https://operately.com/help/check-in-goal	14.txt	passed	rejected	Describes a constraint on drafts, not a user-observable capability.	rejected	A limit of one draft per goal is a constraint, not a user-observable capability.
F1-001-B099	Operately F1-001	b	The system automatically requires a name and a unit when a KPI is created	Name and Unit are required.	https://operately.com/help/create-kpi	07.txt	passed	rejected	A form validation rule, not a capability.	rejected	A required-field validation rule is not a capability.
F1-001-B100	Operately F1-001	b	The system automatically hides the New KPI button from users who can only view or comment on the space	The New KPI button is hidden if you can only view or comment.	https://operately.com/help/create-kpi	07.txt	passed	rejected	Describes a permission-based UI restriction, not a capability.	rejected	Hiding a button for view-only users is a permission restriction, not a capability.
F1-002-B077	It's a Plan F1-002	b	The system automatically refuses to delete an account when it is the only owner of a project outside their own workspaces	The delete is refused while they are the only owner of a project outside their own	https://raw.githubusercontent.com/croffasia/itsaplan/HEAD/docs/self-hosting.md	08.txt	passed	rejected	Describes a deletion safeguard, not a user-observable capability.	rejected	Refusing deletion of a sole project owner's account is a safeguard, not a user capability.
F1-005-B060	DeskcommCRM F1-005	b	The system lets a user manage notifications	Profile, Notifications, Billing	https://raw.githubusercontent.com/melgarafael/DeskcommCRM/HEAD/README.en.md	04.txt	passed	rejected	Bare screen label in a list; the excerpt does not say what a user can do with notifications.	rejected	A bare settings-tab label does not say what a user can do with notifications.
F1-017-B026	ZenTao (now branded Sanplex) F1-017	b	The system automatically prevents a story from being linked to a project unless the story is activated	Only activated story can be linked to the projects and then to be developed.	https://www.sanplex.com/book/zentaomanual/free-open-source-project-management-software-createstories-34	05.txt	passed	rejected	Describes a system constraint on linking, not a user-observable capability.	rejected	Allowing only activated stories to be linked is a constraint, not a user capability.
F1-017-B039	ZenTao (now branded Sanplex) F1-017	b	The system automatically prevents child tasks on tasks done by multiple members	Multiple tasks, tasks done by multiple members, cannot have child tasks.	https://www.sanplex.com/book/zentaomanual/free-open-source-project-management-software-decomposetasks-37	06.txt	passed	rejected	Describes a system constraint on child tasks, not a user-observable capability.	rejected	Forbidding child tasks on multi-member tasks is a constraint, not a user capability.
F1-034-B041	WeCMDB F1-034	b	The system automatically prevents users from adding, modifying or deleting system ENUM types when they try to customize them	it cannot be customized adding,modifying or deleting.	https://raw.githubusercontent.com/WeBankPartners/we-cmdb/HEAD/wiki/docs/wecmdb_glossary_en.md	04.txt	passed	rejected	Glossary describes enum type constraints, not a user-observable automation or capability.	rejected	The glossary entry defines that system enum types are fixed; it is a data-model constraint, not an advertised user capability or automation.
F1-034-B042	WeCMDB F1-034	b	The system automatically prevents users from deleting common ENUM types when they try to delete them	but cannot be deleted as it is common which can be used for other CI	https://raw.githubusercontent.com/WeBankPartners/we-cmdb/HEAD/wiki/docs/wecmdb_glossary_en.md	04.txt	passed	rejected	Glossary describes enum type constraints, not a user-observable automation or capability.	rejected	The glossary entry defines that common enum types cannot be deleted; it is a data-model constraint, not an advertised user capability or automation.
F1-037-B009	FOSSBilling F1-037	b	The system lets an administrator choose a product type for hosting, domains, downloads, licenses, and API keys.	Choose the right product type for hosting, domains, downloads, licenses, and API keys.	https://docs.fossbilling.org/admin-guide/	02.txt	passed	rejected	Bundles several capabilities already covered by separate statements (see F1-037-A019 to A022).	rejected	Bundles several product-type capabilities that separate surviving statements already cover.
F2-001-B071	Asana F2-001	b	The system lets a user use Asana through desktop, web, and mobile apps.	Asana is accessible via desktop app, web browser, and mobile app (available for both Android and iOS users).	https://asana.com/product	01.txt	passed	rejected	Availability of desktop, web and mobile apps is a delivery channel, not a capability.	rejected	Access through desktop, web and mobile apps is a delivery channel, not a capability.
F2-007-B001	Userback F2-007	b	The system lets a user capture screenshot annotations, session replays, console logs, and in-app surveys in one place.	Userback captures screenshot annotations, session replays, console logs, and in-app surveys — all centralized in one place	https://docs.userback.io/docs/welcome	01.txt	passed	rejected	Umbrella statement; its parts are covered by A017, A049, A053 and A026.	rejected	This umbrella sentence is covered piece by piece by the annotation, session replay, console log and survey statements.
F2-015-B016	Pipedrive F2-015	b	The system lets a user map out projects.	Map out complex projects simply and intuitively, making task management and team collaboration a breeze.	https://www.pipedrive.com/en/features	01.txt	passed	rejected	Marketing prose with no specific capability.	rejected	Marketing intro to an integrations category with no specific capability.
F2-019-B050	Xero F2-019	b	The system lets a user manage bookkeeping and accounting on a mobile app.	Manage your business on the go with the Xero app for bookkeeping and accounting	https://www.xero.com/us/accounting-software/all-features/	05.txt	passed	rejected	Vague claim about a mobile app; no specific capability.	rejected	Generic mobile-app claim with no specific capability.
F2-025-B077	Salesforce Field Service F2-025	b	The system lets a user track alerts, timelines, milestones, warranties, cases, work orders, claims and activities throughout the asset lifecycle.	Track alerts, timelines, milestones, warranties, cases, work orders, claims, and activities throughout the asset lifecycle.	https://www.salesforce.com/service/field-service-management/asset-management/	05.txt	passed	rejected	Vague list of tracked record types in a vertical blurb; no specific capability.	rejected	Catch-all list of record types in a vertical blurb, largely covered by the asset 360-degree view and warranty statements.
F2-043-B026	ServiceNow IT Service Management F2-043	b	The system automatically redirects a user from UI16 module links to the equivalent Service Operations Workspace pages when UI16 module link redirection is enabled	navigating through UI16 paths automatically redirects you to the equivalent list or record pages in SOW instead of displaying the UI16 forms or lists.	https://www.servicenow.com/docs/api/khub/maps/eH2O6EPUpf09wX0~2cZBFg/topics/ACZcXVdTEEC8UAvjvEDQ~g/content	04.txt	passed	rejected	UI navigation redirect for an upgrade/admin setting, not a business capability.	rejected	Redirecting legacy UI paths to the new workspace is an upgrade navigation setting, not a business capability.
F2-043-B028	ServiceNow IT Service Management F2-043	b	The system lets an agent manage incidents with contextual information and targeted actions	Agents can manage incidents effectively with contextual information and targeted actions.	https://www.servicenow.com/docs/api/khub/maps/eH2O6EPUpf09wX0~2cZBFg/topics/IuHkukKoSrzunmpTtJoRPA/content	06.txt	passed	rejected	Too generic to be a distinct capability; incident handling is covered by more specific statements.	rejected	Too generic to name a distinct capability; incident handling is covered by the specific surviving statements.
F2-043-B060	ServiceNow IT Service Management F2-043	b	The system lets a service level manager gather service requirements	Gather service requirements and monitor and report on agreed service levels (SLAs).	https://www.servicenow.com/docs/api/khub/maps/eH2O6EPUpf09wX0~2cZBFg/topics/kSjKycBSAxqdKWB1aGBJiA/content	09.txt	passed	rejected	Describes a manager activity rather than a system function; the source only lists it in an application description.	rejected	Gathering service requirements appears only as an application blurb and names no system function.
F2-043-B163	ServiceNow IT Service Management F2-043	b	The system automatically prevents editing of change request fields after the change is authorized	Authorized: The fields are set to read only to prevent unintended changes after approval.	https://www.servicenow.com/docs/api/khub/maps/eH2O6EPUpf09wX0~2cZBFg/topics/uXk8LEj8iwoJoS8~QkyrIA/content	21.txt	passed	rejected	Describes a restriction or validation rule, not a user-observable capability.	rejected	Making fields read only after authorization is an edit restriction, not a capability.
F2-043-B164	ServiceNow IT Service Management F2-043	b	The system automatically prevents setting or changing the primary configuration item of a change request after it leaves the New state	You can set or change the primary configuration item (CI) only while the change request is in the New state.	https://www.servicenow.com/docs/api/khub/maps/eH2O6EPUpf09wX0~2cZBFg/topics/uXk8LEj8iwoJoS8~QkyrIA/content	21.txt	passed	rejected	Describes a restriction or validation rule, not a user-observable capability.	rejected	Limiting changes of the primary CI to the New state is an edit restriction, not a capability.
F2-049-B038	Sage Intacct F2-049	b	The system automatically prevents deleting or editing invoices when they have been paid	You cannot delete nor edit invoices after they	https://www.intacct.com/ia/docs/en_US/help_action/Accounts_Receivable/accounts-receivable-overview.htm	03.txt	passed	rejected	A restriction on editing paid invoices is an accounting control, not a user capability.	rejected	A lock on editing or deleting paid invoices is a restriction, not a user-observable capability.
F2-061-B084	Vanta F2-061	b	The system lets a user assign access reviews independently of the system owner	the ability to assign reviews independently of the system owner has been a timesaver	https://www.vanta.com/products/access-reviews	08.txt	passed	rejected	Evidenced only by a customer testimonial.	rejected	Evidenced only by a customer testimonial.
F2-067-B117	Givebutter F2-067	b	The system automatically prevents logging a transaction to a contact when the contact lacks a first and last name	You cannot log a transaction to a contact without a first and last name.	https://help.givebutter.com/en/articles/10355528-how-to-create-and-edit-contacts	03.txt	passed	rejected	A validation constraint on transactions, not a user-facing capability.	rejected	A data-validation constraint, not a capability.
F2-067-B153	Givebutter F2-067	b	The system automatically limits changing a team’s name, goal, or logo, or deleting the team, to account admins once the team is created	only an account admin can change the team name, goal, or logo, or delete the team.	https://help.givebutter.com/en/articles/1749223-how-to-use-team-fundraising	05.txt	passed	rejected	A permission restriction, not a capability.	rejected	A permission restriction, not a capability.
F2-067-B177	Givebutter F2-067	b	The system automatically withholds receipts from donors when transactions are imported	Imported transactions will not trigger a receipt to the donor.	https://help.givebutter.com/en/articles/2219216-how-to-manage-automatic-receipts-and-thank-you-messages	07.txt	passed	rejected	Describes the absence of a behaviour (imports send no receipt), not a capability.	rejected	Describes the absence of a behaviour, not a capability.
F2-067-B183	Givebutter F2-067	b	The system automatically replaces the Other option with Enter amount when all donation amounts are removed	If all donation amounts are removed, our system detects this and replaces "Other" with "Enter amount".	https://help.givebutter.com/en/articles/2859751-how-to-customize-donation-amounts	08.txt	passed	rejected	A user-interface fallback label, not a capability.	rejected	A fallback label in the interface, not a capability.
F2-067-B193	Givebutter F2-067	b	The system automatically prevents deleting a table that contains attendees	You can only delete an empty table.	https://help.givebutter.com/en/articles/11731317-how-to-create-event-seating-arrangements	09.txt	passed	rejected	A validation constraint on deleting tables, not a capability.	rejected	A validation constraint on deleting tables, not a capability.
F2-073-B060	Success.co F2-073	b	The system lets a user join a team	Step by step guide to join your team in Success.co	https://www.success.co/docs	09.txt	passed	rejected	Only a help-guide title; no capability is described.	rejected	The only evidence is a help-guide heading for onboarding, and it describes no capability.
F2-073-B070	Success.co F2-073	b	The system lets a user use the system in a desktop app and a mobile app	Have Success right at your fingertips with our desktop app	https://www.success.co/docs	09.txt	passed	rejected	Platform availability of desktop and mobile apps, not a capability.	rejected	Having desktop and mobile apps is platform availability, not a capability.

Advanced export

JSON shape: default, array, newline-delimited, object

CREATE TABLE [candidates] ([candidate_id] TEXT PRIMARY KEY, [app_id] TEXT, [run] TEXT, [statement] TEXT, [excerpt] TEXT, [source_url] TEXT, [source_file] TEXT, [script_check] TEXT, [verifier_verdict] TEXT, [verifier_reason] TEXT, [verifier_correction] TEXT, [adjudicator] TEXT, [adjudicator_reason] TEXT, [in_final_set] REAL, FOREIGN KEY ([app_id]) REFERENCES apps(app_id));
CREATE INDEX [idx_candidates_app_id] ON [candidates]([app_id]);
CREATE INDEX [idx_candidates_run] ON [candidates]([run]);
CREATE INDEX [idx_candidates_verifier_verdict] ON [candidates]([verifier_verdict]);
CREATE INDEX [idx_candidates_adjudicator] ON [candidates]([adjudicator]);