pub10: candidates: 1,735 rows where adjudicator = "rejected (duplicate upheld)", in_final

Every statement both blind runs produced (3,819), with its full trail: script check → verifier verdict and reason → adjudicator ruling and reason → whether it is in the final set. Most rejections are duplicates between the two runs.

Data license: Not yet licensed — internal review only · Data source: Ahmed ElBatanony, Innopolis University

1,735 rows where adjudicator = "rejected (duplicate upheld)", in_final_set = "0.0" and run = "b"

descending

✎ View and edit SQL

This data as json, CSV (advanced)

candidate_id ▼	app_id	run	statement	excerpt	source_url	source_file	script_check	verifier_verdict	verifier_reason	adjudicator	adjudicator_reason
F1-001-B001	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user create goals at any level, including company, team, and individual	Create and track goals at any level - company, team, or individual	https://operately.com/help/features-overview	03.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A001	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B002	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user track goals at any level, including company, team, and individual	Create and track goals at any level - company, team, or individual	https://operately.com/help/features-overview	03.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A002	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B003	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user break down complex initiatives into sub-goals	Break down complex initiatives into sub-goals	https://operately.com/help/features-overview	03.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A003	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B004	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user set success criteria for a goal	Set success criteria and timelines that keep teams focused	https://operately.com/help/features-overview	03.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A004	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B005	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user link projects directly to goals	Link projects directly to goals so everyone sees how their work contributes	https://operately.com/help/features-overview	03.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A005	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B006	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user add a description to a goal	Goal Description — Click “Write” to add context about why this goal matters and what success looks like.	https://operately.com/help/create-goal	05.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A006	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B007	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user add measurable targets to a goal	Targets — Click “Add” to create measurable outcomes that track progress.	https://operately.com/help/create-goal	05.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A007	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B008	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user add a checklist of key milestones and deliverables to a goal	Checklist — Add checks to track key milestones and deliverables.	https://operately.com/help/create-goal	05.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A008	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B009	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user set the champion of a goal	Team & Timeline — Set the champion (who owns it), reviewer (who provides oversight), and due date in the sidebar.	https://operately.com/help/create-goal	05.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A009	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B010	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user set the reviewer of a goal	Team & Timeline — Set the champion (who owns it), reviewer (who provides oversight), and due date in the sidebar.	https://operately.com/help/create-goal	05.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A009	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B011	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user set the due date of a goal	Team & Timeline — Set the champion (who owns it), reviewer (who provides oversight), and due date in the sidebar.	https://operately.com/help/create-goal	05.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A009	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B012	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user create multiple goals in sequence without closing the creation dialog	Create more — Toggle this on to keep the dialog open after creating a goal, so you can quickly create multiple goals in sequence.	https://operately.com/help/create-goal	05.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A010	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B013	Operately F1-001	b	The system automatically sets the status of a new goal to pending until the first check-in is submitted	Your new goal will start with a ‘pending’ status until you submit your first check-in.	https://operately.com/help/create-goal	05.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A014	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B014	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user configure baseline access for company members and space members on a goal	Permissions — Configure baseline access for Company members and Space members.	https://operately.com/help/create-goal	05.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A012	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B015	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user grant specific company members direct access to a goal	Direct people access for specific company members	https://operately.com/help/permissions-overview	12.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A013	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B016	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user grant specific contributors access to a project	Contributor access for specific contributors	https://operately.com/help/permissions-overview	12.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A034	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B017	Operately F1-001	b	The system automatically gives a person the most permissive of the applicable grants as their access to a goal	A person’s final goal access comes from the most permissive applicable grant.	https://operately.com/help/permissions-overview	12.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A050	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B018	Operately F1-001	b	The system automatically gives a person the most permissive of the applicable grants as their access to a project	A person’s final project access comes from the most permissive applicable grant.	https://operately.com/help/permissions-overview	12.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A051	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B019	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user configure company-wide access for a space	Company-wide access for all company members	https://operately.com/help/permissions-overview	12.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A048	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B020	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user configure individual member access for explicitly added space members	Individual member access for explicitly added space members	https://operately.com/help/permissions-overview	12.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A048	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B021	Operately F1-001	b	The system automatically restricts a space to explicitly granted members when company-wide access is set to No Access	Setting company-wide access to No Access makes the space secret. In that case, only explicitly granted members can see or use it.	https://operately.com/help/permissions-overview	12.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A049	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B022	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user control the access level of every space, goal, and project	Control access level of every space, goal, and project.	https://operately.com/features	02.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A048	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B023	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user make a space private	You can make any space private using access management tools.	https://operately.com/help/intro-to-spaces	08.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A046	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B024	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user create additional spaces for different teams and departments	Create additional spaces for different teams and departments.	https://operately.com/help/quick-tour	04.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A045	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B025	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user add members to a space	Add people who actively work on your team’s initiatives.	https://operately.com/help/intro-to-spaces	08.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A047	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B027	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user see recent activity across spaces	Activity Feed: See all recent activity across spaces - updates, changes, discussions, and more.	https://operately.com/help/quick-tour	04.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A044	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B029	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user see the progress and status of the ongoing goals and projects of a space	Goals & Projects overview: See progress and status of ongoing work	https://operately.com/help/quick-tour	04.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A053	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B030	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user see all goals and projects across the organization on a company work map	Company Work Map — The big picture. Shows all goals and projects across your entire organization.	https://operately.com/help/work-map-overview	09.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A052	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B031	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user see the goals and projects of a specific department or team on a space work map	Space Work Map — Team focus. Shows goals and projects within a specific department or team.	https://operately.com/help/work-map-overview	09.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A053	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B032	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user see everything the user owns or contributes to on a personal work map, regardless of space	My Work — Personal dashboard. Shows everything you own or contribute to, regardless of which space it lives in.	https://operately.com/help/work-map-overview	09.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A054	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B033	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user filter a work map to all work, goals only, projects only, paused work, or completed items	The tabs at the top let you filter what you see: All work, just goals, just projects, paused work, or completed items.	https://operately.com/help/work-map-overview	09.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A056	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B034	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user switch the projects on a work map between a table view and a timeline view	On Company Work Map and Space Work Map, open the projects tab to switch Work map view between Table and Timeline.	https://operately.com/help/work-map-overview	09.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A057	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B035	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user plan new goals and projects from a quick dialog at the bottom of a work map	The + Add new item link at the bottom of any Work Map opens a quick planning dialog.	https://operately.com/help/work-map-overview	09.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A055	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B037	Operately F1-001	b	The system automatically calculates the progress of a goal from the sum of its targets	Progress bars visualize completion — for goals, this sums up all their targets; for projects, it’s based on milestones.	https://operately.com/help/work-map-overview	09.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A058	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B038	Operately F1-001	b	The system automatically calculates the progress of a project from its milestones	Progress bars visualize completion — for goals, this sums up all their targets; for projects, it’s based on milestones.	https://operately.com/help/work-map-overview	09.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A058	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B039	Operately F1-001	b	The system automatically updates work maps in real time when someone updates a project’s progress or adds a new milestone	When someone updates a project’s progress or adds a new milestone, you’ll see it reflected immediately across all views.	https://operately.com/help/work-map-overview	09.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A059	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B040	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user create a project	There are several ways to create a project in Operately:	https://operately.com/help/create-project	06.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A025	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B041	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user create a project from a project template	Template — Optional. Choose a project template, No template, or Create a project template to open template creation for the selected space.	https://operately.com/help/create-project	06.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A026	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B042	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user save a project as a template	You can also save a project as a template later.	https://operately.com/help/create-project	06.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A027	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B045	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user add a description to a project	Project Description — Click “Add a project description…” to add context about what needs to be done and what deliverables are expected.	https://operately.com/help/create-project	06.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A029	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B046	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user add milestones to a project	Milestones — Click “Add milestone” to create key checkpoints and deadlines.	https://operately.com/help/create-project	06.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A030	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B047	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user add tasks to a project	Tasks — In the tasks tab, add specific tasks and action items that need to be completed.	https://operately.com/help/create-project	06.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A031	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B048	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user set the champion of a project	Team & Timeline — Set the champion (who owns it), reviewer (who provides oversight), and start and due date in the sidebar.	https://operately.com/help/create-project	06.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A032	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B049	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user set the reviewer of a project	Team & Timeline — Set the champion (who owns it), reviewer (who provides oversight), and start and due date in the sidebar.	https://operately.com/help/create-project	06.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A032	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B050	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user set the start date of a project	Team & Timeline — Set the champion (who owns it), reviewer (who provides oversight), and start and due date in the sidebar.	https://operately.com/help/create-project	06.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A032	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B051	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user set the due date of a project	Team & Timeline — Set the champion (who owns it), reviewer (who provides oversight), and start and due date in the sidebar.	https://operately.com/help/create-project	06.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A032	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B052	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user add documents to a project	Docs & Files — Add documents, files, and links on the Docs & Files tab as the project grows.	https://operately.com/help/create-project	06.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A033	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B053	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user add files to a project	Docs & Files — Add documents, files, and links on the Docs & Files tab as the project grows.	https://operately.com/help/create-project	06.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A033	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B054	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user add links to a project	Docs & Files — Add documents, files, and links on the Docs & Files tab as the project grows.	https://operately.com/help/create-project	06.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A033	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld
F1-001-B055	Operately F1-001	b	The system lets a user reorder milestones and tasks	Create or reorder milestones and tasks, adjust milestone deadlines and descriptions, update task status, assignees, or due dates, and open task details for notes and discussion without losing context.	https://operately.com/help/quick-tour	04.txt	passed	rejected	duplicate of F1-001-A035	rejected (duplicate upheld)	duplicate upheld

Advanced export

JSON shape: default, array, newline-delimited, object

CREATE TABLE [candidates] ([candidate_id] TEXT PRIMARY KEY, [app_id] TEXT, [run] TEXT, [statement] TEXT, [excerpt] TEXT, [source_url] TEXT, [source_file] TEXT, [script_check] TEXT, [verifier_verdict] TEXT, [verifier_reason] TEXT, [verifier_correction] TEXT, [adjudicator] TEXT, [adjudicator_reason] TEXT, [in_final_set] REAL, FOREIGN KEY ([app_id]) REFERENCES apps(app_id));
CREATE INDEX [idx_candidates_app_id] ON [candidates]([app_id]);
CREATE INDEX [idx_candidates_run] ON [candidates]([run]);
CREATE INDEX [idx_candidates_verifier_verdict] ON [candidates]([verifier_verdict]);
CREATE INDEX [idx_candidates_adjudicator] ON [candidates]([adjudicator]);