pub10: candidates: 6 rows where app_id = "F1-046", in_final_set = "1.0" and verifier

Every statement both blind runs produced (3,819), with its full trail: script check → verifier verdict and reason → adjudicator ruling and reason → whether it is in the final set. Most rejections are duplicates between the two runs.

Data license: Not yet licensed — internal review only · Data source: Ahmed ElBatanony, Innopolis University

6 rows where app_id = "F1-046", in_final_set = "1.0" and verifier_verdict = "corrected"

descending

✎ View and edit SQL

This data as json, CSV (advanced)

candidate_id ▼	app_id	run	statement	excerpt	source_url	source_file	script_check	verifier_verdict	verifier_reason	verifier_correction	adjudicator	adjudicator_reason	in_final_set
F1-046-A004	Probo F1-046	a	The system lets a user keep a vendor inventory and track data processing agreements	Vendor inventory, automated website risk assessment, DPA/BAA tracking, subprocessor discovery	https://raw.githubusercontent.com/getprobo/probo/HEAD/README.md	01.txt	passed	corrected	Compound statement; vendor inventory is the single capability here, contract tracking is covered by A020.	The system lets a user keep an inventory of vendors.	corrected	Compound statement; agreement tracking is already covered by the surviving third-party contract-tracking statement.	1.0
F1-046-A005	Probo F1-046	a	The system lets a user record processing activities and maintain a data inventory	processing activity records, data inventory	https://raw.githubusercontent.com/getprobo/probo/HEAD/README.md	01.txt	passed	corrected	Compound statement; processing activities are covered separately by A026.	The system lets a user maintain a data inventory.	corrected	Compound statement; processing activity records are covered by a separate surviving statement.	1.0
F1-046-A006	Probo F1-046	a	The system lets a user collect evidence as files and URLs and track implementation state	Evidence collection (files and URLs), implementation state tracking, task assignment	https://raw.githubusercontent.com/getprobo/probo/HEAD/README.md	01.txt	passed	corrected	Compound statement; implementation-state tracking is not a separate evidenced capability.	The system lets a user collect evidence as files and URLs.	corrected	Compound statement; splitting keeps one capability per statement and the bare table cell gives no further detail on implementation-state tracking.	1.0
F1-046-A013	Probo F1-046	a	The system lets an auditor scope audits, map controls, track findings, and generate reports	Audit scoping, control mapping, finding tracking, report generation	https://raw.githubusercontent.com/getprobo/probo/HEAD/README.md	01.txt	passed	corrected	Compound statement; finding tracking is covered by A024, report generation is listed as missed.	The system lets an auditor scope audits and map controls to them.	corrected	Compound statement; finding tracking is covered separately and report generation is accepted as a missed item.	1.0
F1-046-A014	Probo F1-046	a	The system lets a user receive task and comment lifecycle events through webhooks	Use GraphQL, the `prb` CLI, MCP, n8n, and webhooks instead of limiting work to the console.	https://www.probo.com/docs/product/getting-started/product-overview.md	03.txt	passed	corrected	Describes an automation, not a user action.	The system automatically sends task and comment lifecycle events through webhooks when tasks or comments change.	corrected	The source (09.txt: 'Webhooks Receive task and comment lifecycle events') supports it, and event delivery is an automation.	1.0
F1-046-A041	Probo F1-046	a	The system lets an administrator invite and role-manage members in the organization	Invite and role-manage members in the organization	https://www.probo.com/docs/product/identity-and-access	08.txt	passed	corrected	Invitation is a duplicate of A017; only the role-management part is new.	The system lets an administrator assign roles to organization members.	corrected	Inviting members is already covered by A017; only role management is new.	1.0

Advanced export

JSON shape: default, array, newline-delimited, object

CREATE TABLE [candidates] ([candidate_id] TEXT PRIMARY KEY, [app_id] TEXT, [run] TEXT, [statement] TEXT, [excerpt] TEXT, [source_url] TEXT, [source_file] TEXT, [script_check] TEXT, [verifier_verdict] TEXT, [verifier_reason] TEXT, [verifier_correction] TEXT, [adjudicator] TEXT, [adjudicator_reason] TEXT, [in_final_set] REAL, FOREIGN KEY ([app_id]) REFERENCES apps(app_id));
CREATE INDEX [idx_candidates_app_id] ON [candidates]([app_id]);
CREATE INDEX [idx_candidates_run] ON [candidates]([run]);
CREATE INDEX [idx_candidates_verifier_verdict] ON [candidates]([verifier_verdict]);
CREATE INDEX [idx_candidates_adjudicator] ON [candidates]([adjudicator]);