candidates
Data license: Not yet licensed — internal review only · Data source: Ahmed ElBatanony, Innopolis University
82 rows where run = "a" and verifier_verdict = "rejected"
This data as json, CSV (advanced)
Suggested facets: source_file
app_id 20
- Givebutter 13
- ServiceNow IT Service Management 8
- Operately 7
- DeskcommCRM 6
- QloApps 6
- Probo 6
- Xero 6
- Success.co 5
- Salesforce Field Service 4
- Sage Intacct 4
- It's a Plan 2
- ZenTao (now branded Sanplex) 2
- FOSSBilling 2
- Mayan EDMS 2
- Asana 2
- Userback 2
- Pipedrive 2
- WeCMDB 1
- MaintainX 1
- Vanta 1
adjudicator 2
verifier_verdict 1
- rejected · 82 ✖
run 1
- a · 82 ✖
in_final_set 1
- 0.0 82
| candidate_id ▼ | app_id | run | statement | excerpt | source_url | source_file | script_check | verifier_verdict | verifier_reason | verifier_correction | adjudicator | adjudicator_reason | in_final_set |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| F1-001-A022 | Operately F1-001 | a | The system automatically allows only one draft check-in per goal at a time when a draft is saved. | Each goal can have only one draft check-in at a time. | https://operately.com/help/check-in-goal | 14.txt | passed | rejected | Describes a constraint on drafts, not a user-observable capability. | rejected | A limit of one draft per goal is a constraint, not a user-observable capability. | 0.0 | |
| F1-001-A028 | Operately F1-001 | a | The system automatically requires a project start date when a user selects a project template. | Project start date — Required when you select a template. | https://operately.com/help/create-project | 06.txt | passed | rejected | A validation rule on a form field, not a capability. | rejected | A required-field validation rule is not a capability. | 0.0 | |
| F1-001-A069 | Operately F1-001 | a | The system automatically hides the New KPI button when a user can only view or comment on the space. | The New KPI button is hidden if you can only view or comment. | https://operately.com/help/create-kpi | 07.txt | passed | rejected | Describes a permission-based UI restriction, not a capability. | rejected | Hiding a button for view-only users is a permission restriction, not a capability. | 0.0 | |
| F1-001-A070 | Operately F1-001 | a | The system automatically asks a user to choose a cadence when the cadence is not Weekly or Monthly. | If Cadence is not Weekly or Monthly, the form asks you to Choose a cadence. | https://operately.com/help/create-kpi | 07.txt | passed | rejected | A form validation message, not a capability. | rejected | A form validation prompt is not a capability. | 0.0 | |
| F1-001-A072 | Operately F1-001 | a | The system automatically requires edit access to the space, project or goal when a user creates a document. | You need edit access to the space, project, or goal where you want to create a document. | https://operately.com/help/create-document | 10.txt | passed | rejected | States a permission prerequisite, not a capability. | rejected | A permission prerequisite for document creation is not a capability in itself. | 0.0 | |
| F1-001-A086 | Operately F1-001 | a | The system lets a user reuse project templates for recurring work. | Reuse project templates for recurring work | https://operately.com/help/features-overview | 03.txt | passed | rejected | duplicate of F1-001-A026 | rejected (duplicate upheld) | duplicate upheld | 0.0 | |
| F1-001-A087 | Operately F1-001 | a | The system lets a user track KPIs for a space. | Track KPIs for the numbers each space cares about | https://operately.com/help/features-overview | 03.txt | passed | rejected | duplicate of F1-001-A066 | rejected (duplicate upheld) | duplicate upheld | 0.0 | |
| F1-002-A024 | It's a Plan F1-002 | a | The system lets a user draw a line between two notes to show how they connect. | Draw a line between two notes to show one follows from the other. | https://itsaplan.dev/features/notes | 06.txt | passed | rejected | duplicate of F1-002-A023 | rejected (duplicate upheld) | duplicate upheld | 0.0 | |
| F1-002-A069 | It's a Plan F1-002 | a | The system lets a user chat with each AI agent with its own conversation history. | - Built-in chat with each agent, with its own conversation history | https://raw.githubusercontent.com/croffasia/itsaplan/HEAD/README.md | 01.txt | passed | rejected | duplicate of F1-002-A042 | rejected (duplicate upheld) | duplicate upheld | 0.0 | |
| F1-005-A007 | DeskcommCRM F1-005 | a | The system automatically blocks an AI message that promises something not in the catalogue | The guardrail blocked it: that lead time doesn’t exist in your catalogue. | https://deskcomm.com.br/en | 02.txt | passed | rejected | duplicate of F1-005-A006 (the promise check is one of the seven checks) | rejected (duplicate upheld) | duplicate upheld | 0.0 | |
| F1-005-A035 | DeskcommCRM F1-005 | a | The system lets an administrator reset a user's password | | `reset-password.sh` | Resets a user's password | | https://raw.githubusercontent.com/melgarafael/DeskcommCRM/HEAD/README.en.md | 04.txt | passed | rejected | Shell script run on the VPS by the server operator; IT-infrastructure administration, not a business-role feature. | rejected | The excerpt is a server shell script run by the installation operator, which is IT-infrastructure administration rather than an in-app feature. | 0.0 | |
| F1-005-A036 | DeskcommCRM F1-005 | a | The system lets an administrator remove two-factor authentication for a user who lost their phone | | `reset-mfa.sh` | Removes MFA for someone who lost their phone | | https://raw.githubusercontent.com/melgarafael/DeskcommCRM/HEAD/README.en.md | 04.txt | passed | rejected | Shell script run on the VPS by the server operator; IT-infrastructure administration, not a business-role feature. | rejected | MFA removal here is an operator shell script on the server, not a user-facing sign-in feature of the app. | 0.0 | |
| F1-005-A052 | DeskcommCRM F1-005 | a | The system lets a user send in-app notices with severities and stuck-message alerts | a notice center with severities, stuck-message alerts, send-protection controls (window/pace/cap) | https://raw.githubusercontent.com/melgarafael/DeskcommCRM/HEAD/README.en.md | 04.txt | passed | rejected | duplicate of F1-005-A013; the notice center is system-generated, users do not send notices. | rejected (duplicate upheld) | duplicate upheld | 0.0 | |
| F1-005-A056 | DeskcommCRM F1-005 | a | The system lets an administrator back up the database and WhatsApp sessions | | `backup.sh` | Backs up the database + WhatsApp sessions | | https://raw.githubusercontent.com/melgarafael/DeskcommCRM/HEAD/README.en.md | 04.txt | passed | rejected | Shell script run on the VPS by the server operator; IT-infrastructure administration, not a business-role feature. | rejected | Database backup by shell script is IT-infrastructure administration that no business role uses. | 0.0 | |
| F1-005-A057 | DeskcommCRM F1-005 | a | The system lets an administrator restore a backup into an empty database | it only restores into an empty database | https://raw.githubusercontent.com/melgarafael/DeskcommCRM/HEAD/README.en.md | 04.txt | passed | rejected | Shell script run on the VPS by the server operator; IT-infrastructure administration, not a business-role feature. | rejected | Restoring a backup by shell script is IT-infrastructure administration that no business role uses. | 0.0 | |
| F1-017-A032 | ZenTao (now branded Sanplex) F1-017 | a | The system automatically prevents a story that is not activated from being linked to a project. | Only activated story can be linked to the projects and then to be developed. | https://www.sanplex.com/book/zentaomanual/free-open-source-project-management-software-createstories-34 | 05.txt | passed | rejected | Describes a system constraint on linking, not a user-observable capability. | rejected | Allowing only activated stories to be linked is a constraint, not a user capability. | 0.0 | |
| F1-017-A044 | ZenTao (now branded Sanplex) F1-017 | a | The system automatically prevents child tasks from being created for a task assigned to multiple members. | Multiple tasks, tasks done by multiple members, cannot have child tasks. | https://www.sanplex.com/book/zentaomanual/free-open-source-project-management-software-decomposetasks-37 | 06.txt | passed | rejected | Describes a system constraint on child tasks, not a user-observable capability. | rejected | Forbidding child tasks on multi-member tasks is a constraint, not a user capability. | 0.0 | |
| F1-034-A022 | WeCMDB F1-034 | a | The system lets a user manage configuration item data | After click a CI and the data management page is opened | https://raw.githubusercontent.com/WeBankPartners/we-cmdb/HEAD/wiki/docs/wecmdb_user_guide_en.md | 02.txt | passed | rejected | duplicate of F1-034-A009 | rejected (duplicate upheld) | duplicate upheld | 0.0 | |
| F1-037-A012 | FOSSBilling F1-037 | a | The system lets an administrator edit the subject and content of an email template | Modify the subject and content | https://docs.fossbilling.org/admin-guide/email-templates/ | 07.txt | passed | rejected | duplicate of F1-037-A011 | rejected (duplicate upheld) | duplicate upheld | 0.0 | |
| F1-037-A018 | FOSSBilling F1-037 | a | The system lets an administrator sell hosting plans, domains, downloadable products, licenses, and API keys through product types | Choose the right product type for hosting, domains, downloads, licenses, and API keys. | https://docs.fossbilling.org/admin-guide/ | 02.txt | passed | rejected | Bundles several capabilities (hosting, domains, downloads, licenses, API keys) covered by separate statements. | rejected | Bundles several product-type capabilities that separate surviving statements already cover. | 0.0 | |
| F1-043-A010 | QloApps F1-043 | a | The system lets a user add and update the inventory of rooms | Add and update the inventory of your rooms conveniently using the interactive interface of QloApps. | https://qloapps.com/features | 02.txt | passed | rejected | duplicate of F1-043-A009 | rejected (duplicate upheld) | duplicate upheld | 0.0 | |
| F1-043-A032 | QloApps F1-043 | a | The system lets a user offer discount coupons and promotions | Offer discount coupons and promotions and attract more guests to your hotel. | https://qloapps.com/booking-engine/ | 03.txt | passed | rejected | duplicate of F1-043-A007 | rejected (duplicate upheld) | duplicate upheld | 0.0 | |
| F1-043-A041 | QloApps F1-043 | a | The system lets a user collect the personal details of guests with registration forms | Comprehensive Registration forms to collect the personal details of your guests. | https://qloapps.com/booking-engine/ | 03.txt | passed | rejected | duplicate of F1-043-A002 | rejected (duplicate upheld) | duplicate upheld | 0.0 | |
| F1-043-A049 | QloApps F1-043 | a | The system automatically updates the inventory on all connected channels when a booking is created on any distribution channel | When a booking is created on any distribution channel, inventory of the property is updated to all connected channels. | https://qloapps.com/channel-manager/ | 04.txt | passed | rejected | duplicate of F1-043-A048 | rejected (duplicate upheld) | duplicate upheld | 0.0 | |
| F1-043-A052 | QloApps F1-043 | a | The system automatically maps booking details and inventory to connected online travel agency channels | Channel manager is already integrated with QloApps PMS which automatically maps your booking details and inventory on your connected OTA channels. | https://qloapps.com/channel-manager/ | 04.txt | passed | rejected | duplicate of F1-043-A048 | rejected (duplicate upheld) | duplicate upheld | 0.0 | |
| F1-043-A053 | QloApps F1-043 | a | The system automatically manages inventories on all online travel agency channels when a booking or cancellation request comes from any channel or the property management system | Inventories are auto-managed on all OTA channels when a booking or cancellation request comes from any OTA channel or PMS to avoid short, double, or overbookings. | https://qloapps.com/channel-manager/ | 04.txt | passed | rejected | duplicate of F1-043-A048 | rejected (duplicate upheld) | duplicate upheld | 0.0 | |
| F1-046-A009 | Probo F1-046 | a | The system lets a user manage cookie banners and keep consent records | Cookie banner management, tracker detection, consent records | https://raw.githubusercontent.com/getprobo/probo/HEAD/README.md | 01.txt | passed | rejected | duplicate of F1-046-A077 | rejected (duplicate upheld) | duplicate upheld | 0.0 | |
| F1-046-A031 | Probo F1-046 | a | The system lets a user keep records of enrolled devices and their reported posture | Device records represent enrolled endpoints and their reported posture. | https://www.probo.com/docs/product/getting-started/core-concepts.md | 04.txt | passed | rejected | duplicate of F1-046-A016 | rejected (duplicate upheld) | duplicate upheld | 0.0 | |
| F1-046-A051 | Probo F1-046 | a | The system automatically creates the next task when the deadline of a recurring task passes | When the deadline passes, Probo creates the next task: | https://www.probo.com/docs/product/tasks/overview | 09.txt | passed | rejected | duplicate of F1-046-A022 | rejected (duplicate upheld) | duplicate upheld | 0.0 | |
| F1-046-A058 | Probo F1-046 | a | The system automatically updates the other side when a linked task or issue is edited | Once a task is linked, edits on either side update the other: | https://www.probo.com/docs/product/tasks/overview | 09.txt | passed | rejected | duplicate of F1-046-A023 | rejected (duplicate upheld) | duplicate upheld | 0.0 | |
| F1-046-A069 | Probo F1-046 | a | The system lets a user create a compliance portal with a public URL | Creating a portal assigns it a public URL and opens its configuration page. | https://www.probo.com/docs/product/compliance-portal/quickstart | 11.txt | passed | rejected | duplicate of F1-046-A008 | rejected (duplicate upheld) | duplicate upheld | 0.0 | |
| F1-046-A082 | Probo F1-046 | a | The system lets a user store a consent record with the action, category choices, banner version, client context, and timestamp | A consent record stores the action, category choices, banner version, client context, and timestamp reported to Probo. | https://www.probo.com/docs/product/cookie-banner/overview | 12.txt | passed | rejected | duplicate of F1-046-A078 | rejected (duplicate upheld) | duplicate upheld | 0.0 | |
| F1-047-A090 | Mayan EDMS F1-047 | a | The system lets an administrator grant access through roles | Access is granted through roles, so it scales from a handful of users | https://docs.mayan-edms.com/chapters/features.html | 02.txt | passed | rejected | duplicate of F1-047-A089 | rejected (duplicate upheld) | duplicate upheld | 0.0 | |
| F1-047-A104 | Mayan EDMS F1-047 | a | The system automatically checks the authenticity of signatures against stored keys | Authenticity is checked against stored keys, so tampering is detected. | https://docs.mayan-edms.com/chapters/features.html | 02.txt | passed | rejected | duplicate of F1-047-A102 | rejected (duplicate upheld) | duplicate upheld | 0.0 | |
| F2-001-A019 | Asana F2-001 | a | The system lets a user use mobile and desktop apps to work on tasks | Yes, Asana offers mobile apps for iPhone, iPad, and Android, plus desktop apps for Mac and Windows. | https://asana.com/features/project-management | 02.txt | passed | rejected | Availability of mobile and desktop apps is a delivery channel, not a capability. | rejected | Offering mobile and desktop apps is a delivery channel, not a capability. | 0.0 | |
| F2-001-A049 | Asana F2-001 | a | The system lets a user start a timer or log hours on tasks and capture estimates versus actuals | Time tracking lets users start a timer or log hours, capturing estimates versus actuals for future planning. | https://asana.com/features/resource-management | 05.txt | passed | rejected | duplicate of F2-001-A014 | rejected (duplicate upheld) | duplicate upheld | 0.0 | |
| F2-007-A030 | Userback F2-007 | a | The system lets a user add rating, text, and choice questions to a survey | Add any of these from the Add component dropdown at the top of the builder’s Design > Questions tab. | https://support.userback.io/en/articles/16880431-survey-question-types-reference | 10.txt | passed | rejected | Compound umbrella over three question families; each is covered by A031 to A034. | rejected | This umbrella statement over the question families is fully covered by A031 to A034. | 0.0 | |
| F2-007-A064 | Userback F2-007 | a | The system automatically groups similar feedback into themes using AI | AI Themes groups similar feedback into themes automatically, using AI, so you can see patterns across dozens or hundreds of items without reading each one. | https://support.userback.io/en/articles/13265550-ai-features-in-userback | 14.txt | passed | rejected | duplicate of F2-007-A059 | rejected (duplicate upheld) | duplicate upheld | 0.0 | |
| F2-015-A005 | Pipedrive F2-015 | a | The system lets a user manage, qualify and prioritize leads. | Make the most of each opportunity with dedicated features that help with lead management, qualification and prioritization | https://www.pipedrive.com/en/features | 01.txt | passed | rejected | Vague marketing phrase bundling lead management, qualification and prioritization without a specific capability. | rejected | Vague bundle of lead management areas with no specific capability; leads inbox is covered separately. | 0.0 | |
| F2-015-A033 | Pipedrive F2-015 | a | The system lets a user group contacts into segments based on CRM data for email campaigns. | Group contacts based on CRM data for personalized emails and relevant targeting. | https://www.pipedrive.com/en/features/email-integration | 04.txt | passed | rejected | duplicate of A010 | rejected (duplicate upheld) | duplicate upheld | 0.0 | |
| F2-019-A012 | Xero F2-019 | a | The system automatically reconciles bank transactions using rules, matches to existing records, memory of past reconciliations and predictions. | JAX uses four reconciliation methods – Rule, Match, Memory, and Prediction – for a sophisticated approach. | https://www.xero.com/us/accounting-software/bank-reconciliation/ | 03.txt | passed | rejected | duplicate of F2-019-A001 | rejected (duplicate upheld) | duplicate upheld | 0.0 | |
| F2-019-A044 | Xero F2-019 | a | The system lets a user manage the business on a mobile app. | Manage your business on the go with the Xero app for bookkeeping and accounting | https://www.xero.com/us/accounting-software/all-features/ | 05.txt | passed | rejected | Vague claim about managing the business on a mobile app; no specific capability. | rejected | Generic mobile-app claim with no specific capability; specific mobile features are covered elsewhere. | 0.0 | |
| F2-019-A045 | Xero F2-019 | a | The system lets a user connect bank feeds from financial institutions. | Access bank data from 21,000+ global institutions in Xero. | https://www.xero.com/us/accounting-software/all-features/ | 05.txt | passed | rejected | duplicate of F2-019-A002 | rejected (duplicate upheld) | duplicate upheld | 0.0 | |
| F2-019-A057 | Xero F2-019 | a | The system lets a user accept online payments by credit card, debit card, ACH debit, Apple Pay, and Google Pay. | Accept online payments by credit card, debit card, ACH debit, Apple Pay, and Google Pay | https://www.xero.com/us/accounting-software/send-invoices/ | 06.txt | passed | rejected | duplicate of F2-019-A032 | rejected (duplicate upheld) | duplicate upheld | 0.0 | |
| F2-019-A083 | Xero F2-019 | a | The system automatically calculates, files, and pays federal and state taxes, withholds deductions and generates tax forms. | calculates, files, and pays your federal and state taxes for you. It also withholds any deductions and generates tax forms to save you time and help you avoid mistakes. | https://www.xero.com/us/accounting-software/payroll/ | 08.txt | passed | rejected | duplicate of F2-019-A081 | rejected (duplicate upheld) | duplicate upheld | 0.0 | |
| F2-019-A086 | Xero F2-019 | a | The system automatically notifies employees when they have been paid. | Xero instantly notifies them when they’ve been paid. | https://www.xero.com/us/accounting-software/payroll/ | 08.txt | passed | rejected | duplicate of F2-019-A079 | rejected (duplicate upheld) | duplicate upheld | 0.0 | |
| F2-025-A031 | Salesforce Field Service F2-025 | a | The system lets a customer schedule appointments and receive real-time updates about onsite visits. | Empower customers to effortlessly schedule appointments, receive real-time updates, and stay informed about their onsite visits | https://www.salesforce.com/service/field-service-management/ | 01.txt | passed | rejected | duplicate of F2-025-A001 | rejected (duplicate upheld) | duplicate upheld | 0.0 | |
| F2-025-A032 | Salesforce Field Service F2-025 | a | The system lets a technician create new leads from the mobile app. | technicians can even create new leads — turning service calls into revenue-generating opportunities | https://www.salesforce.com/service/field-service-management/software/ | 02.txt | passed | rejected | duplicate of F2-025-A015 | rejected (duplicate upheld) | duplicate upheld | 0.0 | |
| F2-025-A039 | Salesforce Field Service F2-025 | a | The system lets a user ask natural-language questions about operations and get instant answers without building reports. | Built-in conversational analytics let teams ask natural-language questions | https://www.salesforce.com/service/field-service-management/software/ | 02.txt | passed | rejected | duplicate of F2-025-A026 | rejected (duplicate upheld) | duplicate upheld | 0.0 | |
| F2-025-A058 | Salesforce Field Service F2-025 | a | The system lets a dispatcher create and update absences and organize workers by availability and skill. | Your dispatchers can create and update absences and organize workers by availability and skill to identify the best technician for the job. | https://www.salesforce.com/service/field-service-management/what-is-dispatch-management/ | 07.txt | passed | rejected | duplicate of F2-025-A017 | rejected (duplicate upheld) | duplicate upheld | 0.0 |
Advanced export
JSON shape: default, array, newline-delimited, object
CREATE TABLE [candidates] ([candidate_id] TEXT PRIMARY KEY, [app_id] TEXT, [run] TEXT, [statement] TEXT, [excerpt] TEXT, [source_url] TEXT, [source_file] TEXT, [script_check] TEXT, [verifier_verdict] TEXT, [verifier_reason] TEXT, [verifier_correction] TEXT, [adjudicator] TEXT, [adjudicator_reason] TEXT, [in_final_set] REAL, FOREIGN KEY ([app_id]) REFERENCES apps(app_id)); CREATE INDEX [idx_candidates_app_id] ON [candidates]([app_id]); CREATE INDEX [idx_candidates_run] ON [candidates]([run]); CREATE INDEX [idx_candidates_verifier_verdict] ON [candidates]([verifier_verdict]); CREATE INDEX [idx_candidates_adjudicator] ON [candidates]([adjudicator]);