Rejected for a reason other than duplication
| app_id | candidate_id | statement | excerpt | verifier_reason | adjudicator_reason |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| F1-001 | F1-001-A022 | The system automatically allows only one draft check-in per goal at a time when a draft is saved. | Each goal can have only one draft check-in at a time. | Describes a constraint on drafts, not a user-observable capability. | A limit of one draft per goal is a constraint, not a user-observable capability. |
| F1-001 | F1-001-A028 | The system automatically requires a project start date when a user selects a project template. | Project start date — Required when you select a template. | A validation rule on a form field, not a capability. | A required-field validation rule is not a capability. |
| F1-001 | F1-001-A069 | The system automatically hides the New KPI button when a user can only view or comment on the space. | The New KPI button is hidden if you can only view or comment. | Describes a permission-based UI restriction, not a capability. | Hiding a button for view-only users is a permission restriction, not a capability. |
| F1-001 | F1-001-A070 | The system automatically asks a user to choose a cadence when the cadence is not Weekly or Monthly. | If Cadence is not Weekly or Monthly, the form asks you to Choose a cadence. | A form validation message, not a capability. | A form validation prompt is not a capability. |
| F1-001 | F1-001-A072 | The system automatically requires edit access to the space, project or goal when a user creates a document. | You need edit access to the space, project, or goal where you want to create a document. | States a permission prerequisite, not a capability. | A permission prerequisite for document creation is not a capability in itself. |
| F1-001 | F1-001-B043 | The system automatically requires a project start date when a project template is selected | Project start date — Required when you select a template. | A validation rule on a form field, not a capability. | A required-field validation rule is not a capability. |
| F1-001 | F1-001-B080 | The system automatically prevents a goal from having more than one draft check-in at a time | Each goal can have only one draft check-in at a time. | Describes a constraint on drafts, not a user-observable capability. | A limit of one draft per goal is a constraint, not a user-observable capability. |
| F1-001 | F1-001-B099 | The system automatically requires a name and a unit when a KPI is created | Name and Unit are required. | A form validation rule, not a capability. | A required-field validation rule is not a capability. |
| F1-001 | F1-001-B100 | The system automatically hides the New KPI button from users who can only view or comment on the space | The New KPI button is hidden if you can only view or comment. | Describes a permission-based UI restriction, not a capability. | Hiding a button for view-only users is a permission restriction, not a capability. |
| F1-002 | F1-002-B077 | The system automatically refuses to delete an account when it is the only owner of a project outside their own workspaces | The delete is refused while they are the only owner of a project outside their own | Describes a deletion safeguard, not a user-observable capability. | Refusing deletion of a sole project owner's account is a safeguard, not a user capability. |
| F1-005 | F1-005-A035 | The system lets an administrator reset a user's password | | `reset-password.sh` | Resets a user's password | | Shell script run on the VPS by the server operator; IT-infrastructure administration, not a business-role feature. | The excerpt is a server shell script run by the installation operator, which is IT-infrastructure administration rather than an in-app feature. |
| F1-005 | F1-005-A036 | The system lets an administrator remove two-factor authentication for a user who lost their phone | | `reset-mfa.sh` | Removes MFA for someone who lost their phone | | Shell script run on the VPS by the server operator; IT-infrastructure administration, not a business-role feature. | MFA removal here is an operator shell script on the server, not a user-facing sign-in feature of the app. |
| F1-005 | F1-005-A056 | The system lets an administrator back up the database and WhatsApp sessions | | `backup.sh` | Backs up the database + WhatsApp sessions | | Shell script run on the VPS by the server operator; IT-infrastructure administration, not a business-role feature. | Database backup by shell script is IT-infrastructure administration that no business role uses. |
| F1-005 | F1-005-A057 | The system lets an administrator restore a backup into an empty database | it only restores into an empty database | Shell script run on the VPS by the server operator; IT-infrastructure administration, not a business-role feature. | Restoring a backup by shell script is IT-infrastructure administration that no business role uses. |
| F1-005 | F1-005-B060 | The system lets a user manage notifications | Profile, Notifications, Billing | Bare screen label in a list; the excerpt does not say what a user can do with notifications. | A bare settings-tab label does not say what a user can do with notifications. |
| F1-017 | F1-017-A032 | The system automatically prevents a story that is not activated from being linked to a project. | Only activated story can be linked to the projects and then to be developed. | Describes a system constraint on linking, not a user-observable capability. | Allowing only activated stories to be linked is a constraint, not a user capability. |
| F1-017 | F1-017-A044 | The system automatically prevents child tasks from being created for a task assigned to multiple members. | Multiple tasks, tasks done by multiple members, cannot have child tasks. | Describes a system constraint on child tasks, not a user-observable capability. | Forbidding child tasks on multi-member tasks is a constraint, not a user capability. |
| F1-017 | F1-017-B026 | The system automatically prevents a story from being linked to a project unless the story is activated | Only activated story can be linked to the projects and then to be developed. | Describes a system constraint on linking, not a user-observable capability. | Allowing only activated stories to be linked is a constraint, not a user capability. |
| F1-017 | F1-017-B039 | The system automatically prevents child tasks on tasks done by multiple members | Multiple tasks, tasks done by multiple members, cannot have child tasks. | Describes a system constraint on child tasks, not a user-observable capability. | Forbidding child tasks on multi-member tasks is a constraint, not a user capability. |
| F1-034 | F1-034-B041 | The system automatically prevents users from adding, modifying or deleting system ENUM types when they try to customize them | it cannot be customized adding,modifying or deleting. | Glossary describes enum type constraints, not a user-observable automation or capability. | The glossary entry defines that system enum types are fixed; it is a data-model constraint, not an advertised user capability or automation. |
| F1-034 | F1-034-B042 | The system automatically prevents users from deleting common ENUM types when they try to delete them | but cannot be deleted as it is common which can be used for other CI | Glossary describes enum type constraints, not a user-observable automation or capability. | The glossary entry defines that common enum types cannot be deleted; it is a data-model constraint, not an advertised user capability or automation. |
| F1-037 | F1-037-A018 | The system lets an administrator sell hosting plans, domains, downloadable products, licenses, and API keys through product types | Choose the right product type for hosting, domains, downloads, licenses, and API keys. | Bundles several capabilities (hosting, domains, downloads, licenses, API keys) covered by separate statements. | Bundles several product-type capabilities that separate surviving statements already cover. |
| F1-037 | F1-037-B009 | The system lets an administrator choose a product type for hosting, domains, downloads, licenses, and API keys. | Choose the right product type for hosting, domains, downloads, licenses, and API keys. | Bundles several capabilities already covered by separate statements (see F1-037-A019 to A022). | Bundles several product-type capabilities that separate surviving statements already cover. |
| F2-001 | F2-001-A019 | The system lets a user use mobile and desktop apps to work on tasks | Yes, Asana offers mobile apps for iPhone, iPad, and Android, plus desktop apps for Mac and Windows. | Availability of mobile and desktop apps is a delivery channel, not a capability. | Offering mobile and desktop apps is a delivery channel, not a capability. |
| F2-001 | F2-001-B071 | The system lets a user use Asana through desktop, web, and mobile apps. | Asana is accessible via desktop app, web browser, and mobile app (available for both Android and iOS users). | Availability of desktop, web and mobile apps is a delivery channel, not a capability. | Access through desktop, web and mobile apps is a delivery channel, not a capability. |
| F2-007 | F2-007-A030 | The system lets a user add rating, text, and choice questions to a survey | Add any of these from the Add component dropdown at the top of the builder’s Design > Questions tab. | Compound umbrella over three question families; each is covered by A031 to A034. | This umbrella statement over the question families is fully covered by A031 to A034. |
| F2-007 | F2-007-B001 | The system lets a user capture screenshot annotations, session replays, console logs, and in-app surveys in one place. | Userback captures screenshot annotations, session replays, console logs, and in-app surveys — all centralized in one place | Umbrella statement; its parts are covered by A017, A049, A053 and A026. | This umbrella sentence is covered piece by piece by the annotation, session replay, console log and survey statements. |
| F2-015 | F2-015-A005 | The system lets a user manage, qualify and prioritize leads. | Make the most of each opportunity with dedicated features that help with lead management, qualification and prioritization | Vague marketing phrase bundling lead management, qualification and prioritization without a specific capability. | Vague bundle of lead management areas with no specific capability; leads inbox is covered separately. |
| F2-015 | F2-015-B016 | The system lets a user map out projects. | Map out complex projects simply and intuitively, making task management and team collaboration a breeze. | Marketing prose with no specific capability. | Marketing intro to an integrations category with no specific capability. |
| F2-019 | F2-019-A044 | The system lets a user manage the business on a mobile app. | Manage your business on the go with the Xero app for bookkeeping and accounting | Vague claim about managing the business on a mobile app; no specific capability. | Generic mobile-app claim with no specific capability; specific mobile features are covered elsewhere. |
| F2-019 | F2-019-B050 | The system lets a user manage bookkeeping and accounting on a mobile app. | Manage your business on the go with the Xero app for bookkeeping and accounting | Vague claim about a mobile app; no specific capability. | Generic mobile-app claim with no specific capability. |
| F2-025 | F2-025-B077 | The system lets a user track alerts, timelines, milestones, warranties, cases, work orders, claims and activities throughout the asset lifecycle. | Track alerts, timelines, milestones, warranties, cases, work orders, claims, and activities throughout the asset lifecycle. | Vague list of tracked record types in a vertical blurb; no specific capability. | Catch-all list of record types in a vertical blurb, largely covered by the asset 360-degree view and warranty statements. |
| F2-043 | F2-043-A020 | The system automatically redirects UI16 module links to the equivalent Service Operations Workspace pages when redirection is enabled | navigating through UI16 paths automatically redirects you to the equivalent list or record pages in SOW | UI navigation redirect for an upgrade/admin setting, not a business capability. | Redirecting legacy UI paths to the new workspace is an upgrade navigation setting, not a business capability. |
| F2-043 | F2-043-A055 | The system automatically prevents creating another record of the same task type when an incident already has an associated problem or change record | If the incident already has an associated | Describes a restriction or validation rule, not a user-observable capability. | Blocking creation of a second record of the same task type is a validation rule, not a capability. |
| F2-043 | F2-043-A130 | The system automatically prevents editing of the fields of a change request after it is authorized | The fields are set to read only to prevent unintended changes after approval | Describes a restriction or validation rule, not a user-observable capability. | Making fields read only after authorization is an edit restriction, not a capability. |
| F2-043 | F2-043-A131 | The system automatically prevents changing the primary configuration item of a change request after it leaves the New state | You can set or change the primary configuration item (CI) only while the change request is in the New state | Describes a restriction or validation rule, not a user-observable capability. | Limiting changes of the primary CI to the New state is an edit restriction, not a capability. |
| F2-043 | F2-043-B026 | The system automatically redirects a user from UI16 module links to the equivalent Service Operations Workspace pages when UI16 module link redirection is enabled | navigating through UI16 paths automatically redirects you to the equivalent list or record pages in SOW instead of displaying the UI16 forms or lists. | UI navigation redirect for an upgrade/admin setting, not a business capability. | Redirecting legacy UI paths to the new workspace is an upgrade navigation setting, not a business capability. |
| F2-043 | F2-043-B028 | The system lets an agent manage incidents with contextual information and targeted actions | Agents can manage incidents effectively with contextual information and targeted actions. | Too generic to be a distinct capability; incident handling is covered by more specific statements. | Too generic to name a distinct capability; incident handling is covered by the specific surviving statements. |
| F2-043 | F2-043-B060 | The system lets a service level manager gather service requirements | Gather service requirements and monitor and report on agreed service levels (SLAs). | Describes a manager activity rather than a system function; the source only lists it in an application description. | Gathering service requirements appears only as an application blurb and names no system function. |
| F2-043 | F2-043-B163 | The system automatically prevents editing of change request fields after the change is authorized | Authorized: The fields are set to read only to prevent unintended changes after approval. | Describes a restriction or validation rule, not a user-observable capability. | Making fields read only after authorization is an edit restriction, not a capability. |
| F2-043 | F2-043-B164 | The system automatically prevents setting or changing the primary configuration item of a change request after it leaves the New state | You can set or change the primary configuration item (CI) only while the change request is in the New state. | Describes a restriction or validation rule, not a user-observable capability. | Limiting changes of the primary CI to the New state is an edit restriction, not a capability. |
| F2-049 | F2-049-A040 | The system automatically prevents deleting or editing invoices when they have been paid | You cannot delete nor edit invoices after | A restriction on editing paid invoices is an accounting control, not a user capability. | A lock on editing or deleting paid invoices is a restriction, not a user-observable capability. |
| F2-049 | F2-049-A083 | The system automatically prevents exporting a standard application report when it has not been memorized | To export a standard application report, it must be memorized first. | A restriction on exporting unmemorized reports is a limitation, not a capability. | The requirement to memorize a report before export is a precondition, not a capability. |
| F2-049 | F2-049-A087 | The system automatically prevents a user from viewing report data when the user lacks the proper permissions | you must have the proper permissions to view the data in a report. | A permission restriction is not a stated capability; the excerpt describes no permission feature. | The excerpt states a permission precondition and describes no permission feature. |
| F2-049 | F2-049-B038 | The system automatically prevents deleting or editing invoices when they have been paid | You cannot delete nor edit invoices after they | A restriction on editing paid invoices is an accounting control, not a user capability. | A lock on editing or deleting paid invoices is a restriction, not a user-observable capability. |
| F2-061 | F2-061-A006 | The system lets a user customize frameworks, control sets, policies, on- and offboarding processes, risk assessments, access reviews, and vendor security reviews | you can customize frameworks, control sets, policies, on- and offboarding processes, risk assessments, access reviews, vendor security reviews | Compound list of unrelated customizations; the individual capabilities are covered by other statements. | Compound list of customizations, each already covered by separate surviving statements. |
| F2-061 | F2-061-B084 | The system lets a user assign access reviews independently of the system owner | the ability to assign reviews independently of the system owner has been a timesaver | Evidenced only by a customer testimonial. | Evidenced only by a customer testimonial. |
| F2-067 | F2-067-A081 | The system automatically prevents logging a transaction to a contact without a first and last name | You cannot log a transaction to a contact without a first and last name. | A validation constraint on transactions, not a user-facing capability. | A data-validation constraint, not a capability. |
| F2-067 | F2-067-A194 | The system automatically prevents deleting a table that contains attendees | You can only delete an empty table. | A validation constraint on deleting tables, not a capability. | A validation constraint on deleting tables, not a capability. |
| F2-067 | F2-067-A195 | The system automatically prevents seating a group at a table without capacity for the whole group | If you try to seat a large group at a table without capacity for the whole group, you’ll get an error message. | A validation error condition, not a capability. | An error condition, not a capability. |
| F2-067 | F2-067-A197 | The system lets donors and volunteers use a mobile app | Bring the power of Givebutter directly to your donors and volunteers with the Givebutter Mobile App. | Too vague; names no specific capability of the mobile app. | Names no specific capability; the mobile app's concrete features are covered by other statements. |
| F2-067 | F2-067-B117 | The system automatically prevents logging a transaction to a contact when the contact lacks a first and last name | You cannot log a transaction to a contact without a first and last name. | A validation constraint on transactions, not a user-facing capability. | A data-validation constraint, not a capability. |
| F2-067 | F2-067-B153 | The system automatically limits changing a team’s name, goal, or logo, or deleting the team, to account admins once the team is created | only an account admin can change the team name, goal, or logo, or delete the team. | A permission restriction, not a capability. | A permission restriction, not a capability. |
| F2-067 | F2-067-B177 | The system automatically withholds receipts from donors when transactions are imported | Imported transactions will not trigger a receipt to the donor. | Describes the absence of a behaviour (imports send no receipt), not a capability. | Describes the absence of a behaviour, not a capability. |
| F2-067 | F2-067-B183 | The system automatically replaces the Other option with Enter amount when all donation amounts are removed | If all donation amounts are removed, our system detects this and replaces "Other" with "Enter amount". | A user-interface fallback label, not a capability. | A fallback label in the interface, not a capability. |
| F2-067 | F2-067-B193 | The system automatically prevents deleting a table that contains attendees | You can only delete an empty table. | A validation constraint on deleting tables, not a capability. | A validation constraint on deleting tables, not a capability. |
| F2-073 | F2-073-A067 | The system lets a user use the application on a mobile app | Use Success on the go with our mobile app | Platform availability of a mobile app, not a capability. | Having a mobile app is platform availability, not a capability. |
| F2-073 | F2-073-A068 | The system lets a user use the application on a desktop app | Have Success right at your fingertips with our desktop app | Platform availability of a desktop app, not a capability. | Having a desktop app is platform availability, not a capability. |
| F2-073 | F2-073-B060 | The system lets a user join a team | Step by step guide to join your team in Success.co | Only a help-guide title; no capability is described. | The only evidence is a help-guide heading for onboarding, and it describes no capability. |
| F2-073 | F2-073-B070 | The system lets a user use the system in a desktop app and a mobile app | Have Success right at your fingertips with our desktop app | Platform availability of desktop and mobile apps, not a capability. | Having desktop and mobile apps is platform availability, not a capability. |